Lobster Cooker . 4 Wave Avenue, Middletown. Nikki_in_Cali 05:56:58 PM on 06/06/11 . Ranked #1 of 7 Quick Bites in Freeport. If you prefer a lobster roll with no mayo, you can also use butter as the perfect substitute for that. 261 Reviews. Place on a hot dog roll - What a feast! What was this thing, my 19-year-old, California-girl soul said? 39 Main St, Freeport, ME 04032-1212 +1 207-869-5086. Lobster with mayo is more like a salad to me. Lobster Rolls ,No mayo - Lobster Cooker. Their regular lobster roll is the lightest on mayo in the area as well--truly a wisp of mayo. That said, you’ll find both of these styles served in both states, and throughout New England. Flo’s Clam Shack: These Lobster Rolls are pure and simple, no mayo or extra ingredients added, just fresh lobster meat on a roll with mayo on the side. All butters are not created equal. Certificate of Excellence. The bun the lobster is served in, along with how the lobster is dressed (for instance lots of mayo, or no mayo at all) also played a role. Mayo for a lobster roll; butter for a whole or tail endeavor! Choose a quality butter like Kate's Butter, which highlights the sweetness of lobster meat without overpowering the taste. Improve this listing. I can think of no better dish that captures the true taste and tone of summer than a lobster roll. Mayo or no mayo? Celery or celery salt? Website. And then I ate it, and I became a believer. 63 photos. I do remember being surprised at the sight of my first lobster roll on the Cape all those years ago. Chives or scallions? If you go, get the onion rings. Arnold's in Eastham serves a "hot" lobster roll, no mayo, just melted butter. I recently got them cooked to order "extra crispy" since they can be a little beige for my liking, and they accomodated me and they were extra delicious that way! 401-847-8141, FlosClamShacks.com. But there are as many varieties of lobster rolls as there are claims to the 'best-ever lobster roll' fame, so it ultimately comes down to your personal preferences for seafood sandwiches. Connecticut Lobster Rolls contain no mayonnaise. United States ; Maine (ME) Freeport ; Freeport Restaurants ; Lobster Cooker; Search “Lobster Rolls ,No mayo” Review of Lobster Cooker. 5 Replies. They vary in flavor, texture, and moisture levels. https://www.bonappetit.com/test-kitchen/article/best-lobster-roll-recipe I'm from Connecticut - so I guess I'm partial. I had no idea what it was, but I was happy to see lobster for less then $10 and then to see it dressed in mayo?