She just added few other spices, then if there was any leftovers she’d throw in some kidney beans and some sort of meat. Much is cooked and served up in a wide range of hearty dishes. This easy Amish recipe is a farm favorite, made from ruby red tomatoes bathed in a tangy homemade marinade. Peel the tomatoes. The Spruce. The Spruce. Oh, my we’d have bread and another full course meal. Ingredients. Here you'll find Pennsylvania Dutch classics like shoofly pie and apple butter, plus some lesser known favorites like baked oatmeal and creamy macaroni salad. If you prefer to do this, then go for it. Take advantage of your homegrown tomatoes, or the ruby red beauties at the Amish market, and team this healthy salad with any of your favorite main dishes. However, if you are lazy like me, then leave the peels on. Click Play to See This Recipe Come Together. This recipe is for basic stewed tomatoes made with fresh tomatoes, salt and pepper, butter, and sugar. These Amish Harvest Tomatoes are sure to be a family-style hit. Hide Images . 1:26. Of all the Macaroni & Stewed Tomatoes recipes I looked up this is the only one that was 95% close to my grandmothers etc way of making. The peels should come right off. Try some of these classic Amish and Pennsylvania Dutch-style vegetable recipes at your next family meal. Be sure to squeeze out the seeds and excess juice from the tomatoes before chopping. Recipes are meant to fuel long days of manual labor (many communities don't use modern technology), to share at potlucks, and to preserve or use up every part of an ingredient so nothing goes to waste. The easiest way is to boil the tomato for 30 seconds and then put into ice water. Gather the ingredients. Amish eat a lot of home-grown vegetables, including tomatoes, eggplants, spinach, and beets. Some of the garden crop gets canned for the winter (see Amish Canning Recipes). The original recipe for these stewed tomatoes says to peel the tomatoes. 4 large tomatoes (or 6 medium tomatoes) 1 teaspoon salt 1/8 teaspoon pepper 1 tablespoon butter 1/4 teaspoon sugar Steps to Make It.